Abstract:
Crude oils and sediments extracts from Kohat-Potwar Basin (Upper Indus
Basin) were examined for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), heterocyclic
aromatic hydrocarbons, biomarkers and stable isotope compositions. The first four
chapters provide background to the research. Chapter 5 discusses the petroleum
geochemistry of Potwar Basin where three groups of oils were recognized on the basis of
diagnostic biomarkers, distribution of PAHs and stable bulk carbon and hydrogen
isotopes. In chapter 6, PAHs distributions and compound specific stable hydrogen isotope
compositions have been used to assess minor biodegradation in Potwar Basin oils. The
final chapter of this thesis (chapter 7) describes the formation of heterocyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons and fluorenes in sedimentary organic matter through carbon catalysis
reactions.
Diagnostic biomarker parameters along with stable bulk δ13C and δD isotope
abundance reveal three groups of oils in Potwar Basin. Group A contains terrestrial
source of OM deposited in highly oxic/fluvio-deltaic clastic depositional environment
shown by high Pr/Ph, high diahopane/hopane, high diasterane/sterane, low DBT/P ratios
and higher relative abundance of C19 tricyclic and C24 tetracyclic terpanes. Aliphatic
biomarkers for rest of the oils indicate marine origin however two ranges of values for
parameters differentiate them into two sub-groups (B and C). Group B oils are generated
from clastic rich source rocks deposited in marine suboxic depositional environment than
group C oils which are generated from source rocks deposited in marine oxic depositional
environment. Group C oils show higher marine OM (algal input) indicated by extended
tricyclic terpanes (upto C41 or higher) and higher steranes/hopanes ratios. Distribution of
PAHs classified Potwar Basin oils into similar three groups based on depositional
environments and source OM variations. Abundant biphenyls (BPs) and fluorenes (Fs)
are observed in group A oils while group B oils showed higher abundance of
dibenzothiophenes (DBTs) and negligible presence of dibenzofurans (DBFs) and Fs and
group C oils showed equal abundance of DBTs and Fs. This relative abundance of
heterocyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in Potwar Basin oils broadly indicate that the
distribution of these compounds is controlled by depositional environment of OM where
sulfur compounds (i.e. DBTs) are higher in marine source oils while oxygen compounds
(DBFs) and Fs are higher in oxic/deltaic depositional environment oils. Higher
abundance of aromatic biomarkers the 1,2,5-trimethylnaphthalene (1,2,5-TMN), 1-
methylphenanthrene (1-MP) and 1,7-dimethylphenanthrene (1,7-DMP) indicate major
source of OM for group A oil is higher plant supported by abundance of conifer plants
biomarker retene. Variations in distribution of triaromatic steroids (TAS) in Potwar Basin
oils clearly indicate source dependent of these compounds rather than thermal maturity.
Higher abundance of C20 and C21 TAS and substantional difference in distribution of long
chain TAS (C26, C27, C28) between the groups indicate different source origin of these
compounds. Group A shows only C27 and C28 TAS while group B shows C25 to C28 TAS
and absence of these compounds in group C oils revealed that the sterol precursors for
these compounds are most probably different. Aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbon
maturation parameters indicate higher (late oil generation) thermal maturity for all oils
from the Potwar Basin. The crude oils of group A and C are typically non-biodegraded
mature crude oils whereas some of the oils from group B showed minor biodegradation
indicated by higher Pr/n-C17, Ph/n-C18 and low API gravity.
Distribution of PAHs and stable hydrogen isotopic composition (δD) of n-
alkanes and isoprenoids has been used to assess the minor biodegradation in a suite of
eight crude oils from Potwar Basin, Pakistan (group B). The low level of biodegradation
under natural reservoir conditions was established on the basis of biomarker distributions.
Bulk stable hydrogen isotope of saturated fractions of crude oils show an enrichment in D
with increase in biodegradation and show a straight relationship with biodegradation
indicators i.e. Pr/n-C17, API gravity. For the same oils, δD values for the n-alkanes
relative to the isoprenoids are enriched in deuterium (D). The data are consistent with the
removal of D-depleted low-molecular-weight (LMW) n-alkanes (C14-C22) from the oils.
The δD values of isoprenoids do not change during the minor biodegradation and are
similar for all the samples. The average D enrichment for n-alkanes with respect to the
isoprenoids is found to be as much as 35‰ for the most biodegraded sample. The relative
susceptibility of alkylnaphthalenes and alkylphenanthrenes at low levels of
biodegradation was discussed. Alkylnaphthalenes are more susceptible to biodegradation
than alkylphenanthrenes while extent of biodegradation decreases with increase in alkyl
substitution on both naphthalene and phenanthrenes. A range of biodegradation ratios
(BR) are purposed from dimethylnaphthalene (DNBR), trimethylnaphthalenes (TNBR)
and tetramethylnaphthalene (TeNBR) that show significant differences in values with
increasing biodegradation and are suggested as good indicators for assessment of low
level of biodegradation.
Laboratory experiments have shown that activated carbon catalyses the reactions
of biphenyls (BPs) with surface adsorbed reactants that incorporate S, O, N or methylene
forming some common constituents of sedimentary organic matter namely,
dibenzothiophene (DBT), dibenzofuran (DBF), carbazole (C)
and fluorene (F). A
relationship between the % abundance of the hetero element in kerogen and the
abundance of the related heterocyclic compound in the associated soluble organic matter
supports the hypothesis that these reactions occur in nature. More specific supporting
evidence is reported from the good correlation observed between methyl and dimethyl
isomers of the reactant BPs and the methyl and dimethyl isomers of the proposed product
heterocyclics compounds i.e. DBTs, DBFs, Cs and Fs. It is suggested that these
distributions reported for sediments and crude oils from the Kohat Basin are the result of
a catalytic reactions of compounds with BP ring systems and surface adsorbed species of
the hetero element on the surface of carbonaceous material. Similar distributions of
heterocyclic aromatic hydrocarbon from Carnarvon Basin (Australia) were illustrated to
show the global phenomenon of this hypothesis. Furthermore, the abundances of these
compounds (DBT, DBF and BP) show similar concentration profiles throughout the
Kohat Basin sediments suggesting that share a common source. These compounds also
correlate well with changes in the paleoredox conditions. These data tends to point
towards a common precursor perhaps lignin phenols of land plants. Coupling of phenols
leads to BP, which has been demonstrated in laboratory experiments to be the source of
C, DBT, DBF, and F.